Performance Calculation Methodology

Since The Turnaround Letter's inception in 1986, performance calculations have followed a strict methodology based on research provided by impartial independent researcher Hulbert Financial Digest (nka Hulbert Ratings), the industry standard for independent analysis of investment publications. This methodology is based on the perspective of subscribers, executing recommended trades at the prices prevailing when an anonymous subscriber would have first been able to act on the recommendation, and the calculations specifically provide for the following:

  • If the recommendation is received before the opening of NYSE trading, the recommended trade is executed at the average of the security's high and low prices in that day's session.
  • If the recommendation is received after the NYSE opens but before the close of trading, the trade is executed at that day's closing price.
  • If the recommendation is received after the close of NYSE trading, the trade is executed at the average of the security's high and low prices in the subsequent day's session.
  • If an adviser wishes a trade to occur at other prices--such as at the opening, or at limit prices--then that must be explicitly stated.

With this protocol, regardless of whether a market order is executed at the closing or the average price, however, Hulbert Financial Digest adjusts that price upwards (when buying) or downwards (when selling) according to an estimate of that security's bid-offer spread on that day. In addition, Hulbert Financial Digest debits a commission on all transactions, the rate of which is based on average commissions at the nation's largest discount brokers on average-sized transactions. (This rate changes periodically to reflect current conditions.) The one-way commission rates currently are 0.05% for stocks, 1.5% for options and for futures contracts 0.05% of the contract's value. Mutual fund loads and redemption fees are debited.

Hulbert Financial Digest's calculations do not take taxes into account; however, dividends, splits, corporate actions and fund distributions are credited on the day the security goes ex-dividend. The following considerations on performance calculation should also be noted:

  • Purchase stocks only when the market price is below the "buy" limit. Stocks that reach or exceed the "buy" limit or have a recommendation change to a "hold" are considered "sold. If the stock subsequently declined to below the "buy" limit before the publication recommends a sale, the stock is repurchased.
  • Whenever there is a buy/sell transaction, the portfolio is rebalanced back to equal dollar weighting for each position. Purchases are priced at the "ask" price and sells are priced at the "bid" price. Commissions of 0.1% are paid on the traded shares (buys and sells), but not on the other trades in the rebalancing.
  • Dividends are accrued as cash, then reinvested at the next rebalancing.
  • At month-end, portfolios are rebalanced to equal dollar weighting for each position, using month-end closing prices plus accrued dividends.
  • Performance of separate portfolios are aggregated using a simple equal-weighted averaging of their returns. For The Turnaround Letter, the Small-Cap, Mid-Cap and Large-Cap segments are aggregated into the combined overall return in this manner.

Return to The Turnaround Letter Results Page

Identify & Profit from Distressed Investing

Free Report: Turnaround Investing Mistakes

Turnaround Investing Blog

Turnaround Investing Blog

IBM: Not Yet Time to Swing at this Pitch

IBM’s stock underperformance since IBM’s current CEO took the helm in 2012 has been stark, with the shares declining 23% while the S&P500 Index has more than doubled. One big problem: revenue growth rate is zero, at best. Without revenue growth, what’s left to entice investors? The real driver of value at IBM – free cash flow that is used to repurchase shares. Can IBM borrow its way to shareholder prosperity as its cash flows shrink? What to do with IBM shares? Wait for a better pitch in the form of a catalyst or much lower valuation. Read More.

Comparing Stocks Vs. Bonds

While the common stock of a turnaround candidate usually has the greatest upside potential, other classes of securities, such as bonds or preferred stock, may offer attractive profit possibilities with less risk. Many turnaround companies have only one class of securities available to investors but where there are different classes to choose from, it can pay to do a little extra analysis of the various options.

Read More.

Turnaround Letter Stock Pick Named Top Performer of 2017


stock market advicex


What Last Year's Top Stock Pickers Are Buying in 2018


This Forbes write-up follows up on the recent Top Stock Tips report--naming The Turnaround Letter's Crocs recommendation the top performer of 2017: With 90% gains, CROX beat out 100 other investment ideas included in the report; and the stock continues to have value investing appeal, according to Putnam.


George notes, "We see additional upside for the stock in 2018 as management's efforts continue to bear fruit, though the gains will likely be more muted than we saw in 2017."